SOA Document Copyright Infringement? – Revisited

Somersett United
Somersett United

The following quote (attributed to Committee member Samuel Novel) was extracted from the last published SOA Communication Committee Meeting Recap (i.e., September 15).

“Samuel asked Susan about the Board challenging the Somersett United website and their use of copying association documents from the association’s secured website to their public site. Somersett United should be using a link to the association’s website to ensure owners are logging in to review association documentation. The committee discussed the association’s ability to copyright each document and potentially submitted a complaint to the host site of Somersett United for copyright infringement. Susan and Lauren will work with the attorney and board members for further action and pursuit. “

This issue has been addressed in the past (i.e., see post of August 2015 entitled “SOA Document Copyright Infringement?”), wherein this website defended its right to publish Association documents (e.g., those contained under the Reference tab of this website), as having been made publicly available and not restricted for re-publishing under any copyright infringement laws. In fact the Association’s governing documents are readily available to any realtors or prospective Somersett buyers.  Additionally, in many incidents, SU has referenced readers to the Association website for more complete information regarding Association documents and/or business.

As previously stated, there is certainly no malice or profit intended in the re-publishing of Association documents, rather it is for the convenience of our readers.  Especially given that most of these documents are not available on the Association’s website, but only on the FirstService Residential website, wherein they are very difficult to find.

Perhaps Committeeman Novel could explain what he believes the harm to the Association is by publishing these documents on this website.   Surely the Association has better use of discretionary funds than pursuing this issue with the Association’s attorneys.  That said, it has been two months since Committeeman Novell’s request and to date this website has not received any communication from the Association or its Agents regarding such.

Needless to say, Somersett United does not see what the fuss is all about. Could it be that Committeeman Novel has some other axe to grind with Somersett United?

2 thoughts on “SOA Document Copyright Infringement? – Revisited

  1. I appreciate Somersett United, particularly given I work remotely (SF) and have family in Somersett and we are constantly challenged to siphon through all the information impacting our home, lifestyle, special assessments that crop up from the few overpowering the many who derive no, limited or questionable benefit from the agendas of the few.
    Somersett United is a fresh voice of reason and measure response to what is found in the “tunnels” of data that emerge from SOA communications, the now First Service Residential website, but the SOA hiring an attorney to contest the re-publication of SOA information vital to our interests is quite simply NOT copyright infringement, given the attribution/summarization of the details and links to the originals. I am furious at this development and will not tolerate the use of our funds in yet another wasted effort. Keep up the good work and thanks to you for diligently keeping us all informed! Good on ya!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s